Skip to content

Bagel Cart

There are no fresh, yummy bagels in your cart right now ☹️

Article: It's Creepy-licious! Pumpkin Spice Bagels Are Here

bagels for Halloween

It's Creepy-licious! Pumpkin Spice Bagels Are Here

For about a month now customers have been asking: When are you baking those Pumpkin Spice bagels again? Well, we hate seeing Back to School ads in July, or Holiday Sales that begin in October. In other words, everyone just hadta wait till the time is right😅

But now, dear friends, that time has arrived. Our beloved Pumpkin Spice bagels are back for the season. These fresh Pumpkin Spice bagels are rolled by hand in New York City, boiled 'n baked, and shipped fresh to you with free 2-day shipping.

They come complete with a special orange tint plus creepy black stripes. Our bakers add just a tad of Chai Masala tea and Molasses to give them that special, spicy zing. But unlike some contenders in the pumpkin spice arms race now upon us, we don't overpower you with spice. It's just a shtickle 'round here. A feast for not only your tastebuds, but your eyes too!

pumpkin spice sandwich

It's time to indulge in a spine-chilling culinary delight like no other. Try 'em toasted with cream cheese, or butter. Customers have been creating interesting sandwiches too. But hurry, cuz come Nov they'll be gone. Happy Halloween!


Read more

bagel facts

Bagel Bites: 7 Fun Facts to Chew On!

Up your New York Bagel IQ with seven mind-blowing bagel facts from New Yorker Bagels.

Read more
send bagel gifts

Multi-Gifting has arrived - Just send bagels!

New! Send a box of fresh NYC bagels to your entire list, by placing just ONE order. What a time saver! As always, enjoy free express shipping too.

Read more