New Yorker Bagels

NYC Bagel of the Month Clubs

We're pleased to offer all authentic bagel lovers the NYC Bagel Club. With this feature, you can easily get fresh, hand-rolled New York City bagels delivered automatically, at an interval you choose.

Club members always enjoy an additional 7-10% off, in addition to the free overnight shipping we provide. Update: we now have over 4,000 Bagel Club members!

There are 3 different ways to join da club:

bagel of the month

Custom Bagel of the Month

More Control -

You Can:
Select 4 bagel flavors
Change bagel flavors between shipments
Pause a subscription
Change frequency 
Updating shipping address
Change your next delivery date
Updating payment info

To Join:

1. Select an option below.
2. Then set Frequency.
3. Click 'Select Flavors'

1 Dozen Custom Box - $39.503 Dozen Custom Box - $74.79

Please be sure to create an account when checking out. Accounts are optional, but you cannot edit or manage a subscription without an account.

Specific Flavor Subscription

Simplest. If you ❤️one specific bagel -

You Can:
Pause a subscription
Change frequency
Updating shipping address
Change your next delivery date
Update payment info
Monthly or Weekly
Lowest price

To Join:

This option is available on each individual bagel page. To set this up, just click the 'Subscribe' circle on the bagel flavor you'd like to receive, then click 'Add to Bagel Cart'

Select a Flavor - $35.55bagel club

Bagel of the Month Gift

Give a Bagel of the Month to someone else -

How Gifts Work:
Bagel flavors are preset
Gifts are pre-paid
Select a 3, 6, 9 or 12 month gift.
Maximum Discount (at 12 months)
3 Flavor Options: Classic or Minis

To Gift:

1. Visit a Bagel of the Month Gifts page below 
2. Select Number of Months
3. Click 'Complete Bagel Subscription' 

Classic Bagel-of-the-Month GiftMini Bagel-of-the-Month Gift

More Help


Please login to your account at to pause, edit or change date of your next shipment!

Bagel Subscription Club Notes:

Delivery changes: If your next order processing date falls on a Friday, Saturday or Sunday, your bagels will be shipped the following Monday and arrive to you Tuesday.
Bagels ordered are for personal consumption or gifts only - they may not be re-sold.
An order cannot be paused past one day of its automated processing date.
All subscription customers agree to our Terms of Service. 

Please visit our Detailed Bagel Club Help Page for more information. Thank you!