Enjoy FREE Overnight Shipping*! Order now.

Enjoy FREE Overnight Shipping*! Order now.

Drop your flavor here
$79.00 $64.50

Custom Box, 2 Dozen Hand-rolled NYC Bagels

Create your custom box! Select 4 bagel flavors

1
Pack 1

2
Pack 2

3
Pack 3

4
Pack 4

apple bagel

Apple Cinnamon

blueberry bagels

Blueberry

Cinnamon Raisin Bagels

Cinnamon Raisin

healthy bagel

Cranberry Energy

fresh egg bagel

Egg

egg everything bagels

Egg Everything

real everything bagels

Everything

french toast bagel

French Toast

garlic bagels

Garlic

jalapeño bagels

Jalapeño Red Pepper

olive bagel

Kalamata Olive

rye bagel

Marble Rye

fresh onion bagel

Onion

new york plain bagel

Plain

poppyseed bagels

Poppy

pumpernickel bagel

Pumpernickel

healthiest bagel

Quinoa Multigrain

order rainbow bagels

Rainbow

order sesame bagels

Sesame

fresh whole what bagels

Whole Wheat

whole wheat bagels

Whole Wheat Everything

fresh bialys

Bialys

Build an assortment of fresh New York City bagels by selecting 4 options from our 22 available flavors.

Note: This package includes options to order Everything, Onion or Garlic. The intense garlic or onion aroma of these flavors may adhere slightly to flavors during shipping. Thank you.

Details
  • 2 dozen fresh, hand-rolled, large NYC bagels
  • Shipped fresh to you with overnight shipping included
  • No preservatives of any kind
  • No bromated flour; No Saturated fat or Trans fat
  • Certified Star-K Kosher
  • Hand rolled and packed in a New Yorker Bagels gift box
  • Add a complimentary gift message
Ingredients

Allergen Statement

New Yorker Bagels is not a certified nut free environment, although none of our products contain any nuts. Residual nut contamination from ingredient supplies is possible, though unlikely.

The only common allergens that are present in our products are wheat, soy and sesame. All of our bagels contain wheat and soy. Please see ingredient lists below for information on a specific bagel flavor.

Vegan Statement

None of our bagels contain animal products with the exception of natural honey. Some items contain honey.

Build an assortment of fresh New York City bagels by selecting 4 options from our 22 available flavors.

Note: This package includes options to order Everything, Onion or Garlic. The intense garlic or onion aroma of these flavors may adhere slightly to flavors during shipping. Thank you.

Details
  • 2 dozen fresh, hand-rolled, large NYC bagels
  • Shipped fresh to you with overnight shipping included
  • No preservatives of any kind
  • No bromated flour; No Saturated fat or Trans fat
  • Certified Star-K Kosher
  • Hand rolled and packed in a New Yorker Bagels gift box
  • Add a complimentary gift message
Ingredients

Allergen Statement

New Yorker Bagels is not a certified nut free environment, although none of our products contain any nuts. Residual nut contamination from ingredient supplies is possible, though unlikely.

The only common allergens that are present in our products are wheat, soy and sesame. All of our bagels contain wheat and soy. Please see ingredient lists below for information on a specific bagel flavor.

Vegan Statement

None of our bagels contain animal products with the exception of natural honey. Some items contain honey.

Customer Reviews

Based on 268 reviews
92%
(247)
4%
(11)
4%
(10)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
E
Elizabeth Davidow
I was raised on bagels and I am now 85 years ago.

Since moving to Palm Desert California I forgot how a good pumpernickel bagel
tasted until I ordered from New York Bakery. Yes, I am hook again on these gems.

M
Mark Smith
Amazing Bagels!

These are great bagels, so soft and chewy. Flavors do not disappoint. Had some fresh when I got them and froze the rest. Might be even better out of the freezer.

T
Tina Kastner
Fresh and delicious!

Very fresh and delicious! And super fast shipping! Will order again!

e
elena martinez hunter
Best bagels ever

Truly the best ny bagels I've ever eaten
Thick chewy great flavor

J
Joe Hughes
Great gift for former NYer

I sent this as a gift to my NY born brother & his family in Connecticut. They went crazy & loved all the flavors of bagels. He worked at a famous bagel deli when he was a kid, he knows his bagels & he was delighted as were the kids. Thanks New Yorker Bagel for making everyones day.

I
Irene Arbatowicz
Great bagels!

These are the closest to the Long Island bagels that we grew up on but have missed since moving south a few years ago. The only reason I’m not giving 5 stars is I’m surprised that in all the instructions that were emailed and sent in the box, it didn’t say anywhere if you can freeze them in the plastic sleeves they came in. That plastic didn’t seem freezer worthy so I put them in freezer bags. Other than that I would definitely buy these again. They’re worth it!

S
Sandra Schoonmaker
My bagels

I moved to Tennessee 10 years ago. And missed new york bagels. I love them.

Build an assortment of fresh New York City bagels by selecting 4 options from our 22 available flavors.

Note: This package includes options to order Everything, Onion or Garlic. The intense garlic or onion aroma of these flavors may adhere slightly to flavors during shipping. Thank you.

Details
  • 2 dozen fresh, hand-rolled, large NYC bagels
  • Shipped fresh to you with overnight shipping included
  • No preservatives of any kind
  • No bromated flour; No Saturated fat or Trans fat
  • Certified Star-K Kosher
  • Hand rolled and packed in a New Yorker Bagels gift box
  • Add a complimentary gift message
Ingredients

Allergen Statement

New Yorker Bagels is not a certified nut free environment, although none of our products contain any nuts. Residual nut contamination from ingredient supplies is possible, though unlikely.

The only common allergens that are present in our products are wheat, soy and sesame. All of our bagels contain wheat and soy. Please see ingredient lists below for information on a specific bagel flavor.

Vegan Statement

None of our bagels contain animal products with the exception of natural honey. Some items contain honey.

Customer Reviews

Based on 268 reviews
92%
(247)
4%
(11)
4%
(10)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
E
Elizabeth Davidow
I was raised on bagels and I am now 85 years ago.

Since moving to Palm Desert California I forgot how a good pumpernickel bagel
tasted until I ordered from New York Bakery. Yes, I am hook again on these gems.

M
Mark Smith
Amazing Bagels!

These are great bagels, so soft and chewy. Flavors do not disappoint. Had some fresh when I got them and froze the rest. Might be even better out of the freezer.

T
Tina Kastner
Fresh and delicious!

Very fresh and delicious! And super fast shipping! Will order again!

e
elena martinez hunter
Best bagels ever

Truly the best ny bagels I've ever eaten
Thick chewy great flavor

J
Joe Hughes
Great gift for former NYer

I sent this as a gift to my NY born brother & his family in Connecticut. They went crazy & loved all the flavors of bagels. He worked at a famous bagel deli when he was a kid, he knows his bagels & he was delighted as were the kids. Thanks New Yorker Bagel for making everyones day.

I
Irene Arbatowicz
Great bagels!

These are the closest to the Long Island bagels that we grew up on but have missed since moving south a few years ago. The only reason I’m not giving 5 stars is I’m surprised that in all the instructions that were emailed and sent in the box, it didn’t say anywhere if you can freeze them in the plastic sleeves they came in. That plastic didn’t seem freezer worthy so I put them in freezer bags. Other than that I would definitely buy these again. They’re worth it!

S
Sandra Schoonmaker
My bagels

I moved to Tennessee 10 years ago. And missed new york bagels. I love them.

Select your delivery