Create your own assortment! Select 4 bagel flavors using the options above.
Use Promo Code 'Custom' to save 10% today. 

Here’s your chance to build your own assortment of fresh, hand-rolled New York bagels (and bialys!) by selecting 4 options above from our 22 available bagel and bialy flavors.

pssst... Save big-time with a 3-dozen Box instead.

NEW! You can now subscribe to this Custom Box to always have the best… and save! Click here to join the NYC Bagel Club!

This assortments includes:

• 1 dozen fresh, hand-rolled, large NYC bagels: 4 sleeves of 3
• Shipped fresh to you with free overnight shipping included
• No preservatives of any kind
• No bromated flour; No Saturated fat or Trans fat
• Certified Star-K Kosher
• Hand rolled and packed in a New Yorker Bagels gift box

Note: This package includes options to order Everything, Onion or Garlic bagels or Bialys. The intense garlic or onion aroma of these flavors may adhere slightly to flavors during shipping. Thank you.