Enjoy FREE Overnight Shipping*! Order now.

Enjoy FREE Overnight Shipping*! Order now.

Pumpernickel Bagels

$39.50

The classic Pumpernickel Bagel may get overlooked because no one is quite sure what goes well with it. The simple answer is, everything goes well with our savory pumpernickel!

If you enjoy something on any other bagel, odds are you will like it on Pumpernickel too! That said, there are some time-tested toppings that can take a tasty plain New Yorker Pumpernickel Bagel to a new level of flavor. Bagel topping ideas:

  • Any kind of spread is a winner, but salmon or pimento go particularly well.
  • Bologna or Liverwurst are classic companions of pumpernickel. You may want to stash a little at the office for an extra special midday treat.
  • Pretty much any kind of cheese spread, particularly cheddar or a smoked cheese, is bound to satisfy your cravings.

Don’t want 12 Pumpernickel Bagels? You can also Build Your Own Assortment!

  • 1 dozen fresh, hand-rolled, large New York Pumpernickel bagels
  • Shipped fresh to you with overnight shipping included
  • No preservatives of any kind; No bromates or bromated flour
  • No Saturated fat or Trans fat
  • Certified Star-K Kosher
  • Hand-rolled and packed in a New Yorker Bagels gift box
  • Add a complimentary gift message

hand rolled NYC bagels

UNBLEACHED UNBROMATED ENRICHED WHEAT FLOUR, WATER, RYE PUMPERNICKEL FLOUR, BROWN SUGAR, MALT SYRUP, contains 2% or less of each of the following: CARAMEL COLOR, SEA SALT, CARAWAY SEEDS, RAISIN JUICE CONCENTRATE, YEAST, MALT POWDER, MOLASSES POWDER, SOYBEAN OIL, WHEAT GLUTEN, ASCORBIC ACID, ENZYMES.
Pumpernickel Bagel Nutrition

Allergen Statement

New Yorker Bagels is not a certified nut free environment, although none of our products contain any nuts. Residual nut contamination from our ingredient supplies is possible, though unlikely. 

The only common allergens that are present in our products are wheat and sesame. All of our bagels contain wheat.

Vegan Statement

None of our bagels contain animal products - they are 100% Vegan.

Customer Reviews

Based on 12 reviews
92%
(11)
0%
(0)
8%
(1)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
R
Rita Borden
The best!

Delicious !

D
David Bitters
Best outside of NY

I use to live in NY and moved to SC. You can’t beat these bagel outside of NY. They did not skim on the size either. Great to know in all my years I’m not seeing “muffin shrinkage “. Taste and freshness is there. Worth every bite. I raise my bagel and coffee to job well done.

H
Helen Blazanin

They loved your bagels but had problems with the delivery

B
Bill Bruckner
My favorite

I am a big fan of New Yorker Bagel's pumpernickel bagels. It reminds me of the hearty pumpernickel bread I used to eat as a child. These bagels beg to be smeared with lots of cream cheese. A cup of coffee, the newspaper, and pumpernickel bagels are the life for me.

J
Julianne Lee
Pumpernickel

I've had the pumpernickel before, but they weren't as fresh this time.

N
Nina Pearlmutter
Good bagels

It is hard to find actual good bagels in Maine, and impossible to find pumpernickel ones. These are good.

T
Theresa Van Camp
Bagels

We love all your bagels. Very chewy

Customer Reviews

Based on 12 reviews
92%
(11)
0%
(0)
8%
(1)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
R
Rita Borden
The best!

Delicious !

D
David Bitters
Best outside of NY

I use to live in NY and moved to SC. You can’t beat these bagel outside of NY. They did not skim on the size either. Great to know in all my years I’m not seeing “muffin shrinkage “. Taste and freshness is there. Worth every bite. I raise my bagel and coffee to job well done.

H
Helen Blazanin

They loved your bagels but had problems with the delivery

B
Bill Bruckner
My favorite

I am a big fan of New Yorker Bagel's pumpernickel bagels. It reminds me of the hearty pumpernickel bread I used to eat as a child. These bagels beg to be smeared with lots of cream cheese. A cup of coffee, the newspaper, and pumpernickel bagels are the life for me.

J
Julianne Lee
Pumpernickel

I've had the pumpernickel before, but they weren't as fresh this time.

N
Nina Pearlmutter
Good bagels

It is hard to find actual good bagels in Maine, and impossible to find pumpernickel ones. These are good.

T
Theresa Van Camp
Bagels

We love all your bagels. Very chewy