New Yorker Bagels Gift Card

These are the perfect texture and flavor. They’re oversized, and compliment whatever schmear you want to put on them although we’re purists so butter or cream cheese only. (Or lox, or jam, or turkey or or or…) Will order again. May go eat another one right now!

1 Dozen Bagel Gift Box

Best bagels we have ever had. Soft and chewy on the inside and toasted on the outside.

Haven’t tried them yet but disappointed to read all the prep needed before eating, rather than just popping in the toaster. Who wants to heat their oven up to 400 just eat a bagel.

Arrived in two days as advertised. We had just returned from New York vacation so had just had some while there. These were great! Glad I saw the ad on Facebook! Will buy again.

These folks know how to create bagels NY style. Other mail order bagels don’t come close.

Got my first order ! Honest review from this NY transplant to CA. Well, anything is better than what I can get here in the Southern California desert ! With that said , my first impression was that they were a bit too airy and light inside and not crispy enough on the outside. I like a dense bagel. I then read the box insert which explains that transport can change the texture and that de-bagging them for 15 min or so and then freezing them is recommended. It definitely did help. I finally have the closest thing to the bagels of NY that I so miss. Bialys were too doughy , but had the great NY taste.