FREE 2-Day Shipping from NYC! Order

New York Bagels
New Yorker Bagels

FREE 2-Day Shipping from NYC! Order

New Yorker Bagels
Home / Bagels / Fresh Bagel Gifts / New Yorker Bagels Gift Card
bagel giftcard

New Yorker Bagels Gift Card

Give the gift of hand-rolledness!

Our Gift Cards are emailed to you (the purchaser) - you can then forward the Gift Card email with a note or print out to give as a gift.

Card values are stored, so gift cards can be used for multiple purchases at different times! Our gift cards have no additional processing fees, and are good for 18 months after purchase.

$25.00

Customer Reviews

Based on 864 reviews
86%
(745)
6%
(51)
4%
(34)
2%
(14)
2%
(20)
100.0
100.0
D
Dagmar Berry
My favorite bagels

Absolutely love these bagels. Most of the time I get the whole wheat everything.I have been thinking about getting different flavor but always end up with my favorite. Maybe sometime....

L
Linda Crain
Bagel birthday

The bagels were great and my daughter was happy getting them on her birthday

B
BARBARA DYER
Best poppyseed bagels!

I live in a part of Georgia that has no place for fresh bagels. When I found New Yorker bagels online, I thought I would give them a try. Wonderful, wonderful bagels, and service. A bit pricey, especially for the South, but what are you gonna do? Re-order as I did.

k
kathryn schwaebler
Fantastic

Love New Yorker Bagels. Tastes just like home

R
Robin Mehl

1 Dozen Bagel Gift Box

L
Laura Hughes
Bagel Heaven

Oh how sweet it is to eat a bagel that taste like a bagel should! I'm spoiled now. New Yorker Bagels put every shop and store brand I have tried to shame. Thanks for the gastronomical heaven!

D
Debra Harless
Disappointed

The bagels arrived in a timely manner. They seemed fresh and very large. But the Blueberry had little flavor. Only small pieces of blueberries throughout the bagel. The Everything was too strong. I could smell it outside the delivery box. I really wanted to love them.

Hello Debra!

Thank you so much for taking the time to share your feedback!
We're glad to hear that your bagels arrived quickly and fresh. That said, we're sorry to learn that the Blueberry flavor didn’t meet your expectations and that the Everything bagel was a bit overpowering for your taste.
Our bagels are baked fresh in New York City using all-natural ingredients, without any preservatives or artificial flavor enhancers. As a result, the flavor can be more subtle compared to mass-produced products that include additives.
We also include a disclaimer on our website to note that certain flavors—like Garlic, Onion, and Everything—can have a strong scent, especially when packed together.

We truly appreciate your review and our customer suport team has reached out to you to further assist in this matter!

123

Shopping for someone else but not sure what to give them? Give them the gift of hand-rolledness!

New Yorker Bagels gift cards are simple to buy and to use – they are delivered by email and contain instructions to redeem them on our website. Our gift cards have no additional processing fees, and are good for 12 months after purchase.

Our Gift Cards are emailed to you (the purchaser) - you can then forward the Gift Card email with a note or print out to give as a gift.

Card values are stored, so gift cards can be used for multiple purchases at different times!

Customer Reviews

Based on 864 reviews
86%
(745)
6%
(51)
4%
(34)
2%
(14)
2%
(20)
100.0
100.0
D
Dagmar Berry
My favorite bagels

Absolutely love these bagels. Most of the time I get the whole wheat everything.I have been thinking about getting different flavor but always end up with my favorite. Maybe sometime....

L
Linda Crain
Bagel birthday

The bagels were great and my daughter was happy getting them on her birthday

B
BARBARA DYER
Best poppyseed bagels!

I live in a part of Georgia that has no place for fresh bagels. When I found New Yorker bagels online, I thought I would give them a try. Wonderful, wonderful bagels, and service. A bit pricey, especially for the South, but what are you gonna do? Re-order as I did.

k
kathryn schwaebler
Fantastic

Love New Yorker Bagels. Tastes just like home

R
Robin Mehl

1 Dozen Bagel Gift Box

L
Laura Hughes
Bagel Heaven

Oh how sweet it is to eat a bagel that taste like a bagel should! I'm spoiled now. New Yorker Bagels put every shop and store brand I have tried to shame. Thanks for the gastronomical heaven!

D
Debra Harless
Disappointed

The bagels arrived in a timely manner. They seemed fresh and very large. But the Blueberry had little flavor. Only small pieces of blueberries throughout the bagel. The Everything was too strong. I could smell it outside the delivery box. I really wanted to love them.

Hello Debra!

Thank you so much for taking the time to share your feedback!
We're glad to hear that your bagels arrived quickly and fresh. That said, we're sorry to learn that the Blueberry flavor didn’t meet your expectations and that the Everything bagel was a bit overpowering for your taste.
Our bagels are baked fresh in New York City using all-natural ingredients, without any preservatives or artificial flavor enhancers. As a result, the flavor can be more subtle compared to mass-produced products that include additives.
We also include a disclaimer on our website to note that certain flavors—like Garlic, Onion, and Everything—can have a strong scent, especially when packed together.

We truly appreciate your review and our customer suport team has reached out to you to further assist in this matter!

123