Skip to content

Bagel Cart

There are no fresh, yummy bagels in your cart right now ☹️

Home / Individual Flavors / Plain Bagels

Plain Bagels

(147)

Some may think a Plain Bagel is boring, to the purist there is none better. A hand-rolled, fresh, plain bagel crafted by New Yorker Bagels has some attributes that take it from ordinary to something you absolutely adore sinking your teeth into. This classic Plain Bagel has a lovely golden crust, shiny and hard on the surface, with a glossy appearance unmarred by any topping. 

You get 2 dozen fresh, hand-rolled NYC bagels, shipped fresh to you with free 2-day shipping. No preservatives, no saturated fat, Star-K, pas Yisroel Kosher certified.

While some may think the Plain Bagel is boring, to the purist there is none better. A hand-rolled, fresh plain bagel baked by New Yorker Bagels has some attributes that take it from ordinary to something you absolutely adore sinking your teeth into.

This classic Plain Bagel has a lovely golden crust, shiny and hard on the surface, with a glossy appearance unmarred by any topping. Anything that is added to a plain bagel automatically removes its claim to the name, “plain!”

Our Plain Bagel is just soft enough to tear into with your teeth, the crust giving way to a well-risen inside that is chewy without being tough. This is a real New York bagel, not a soft, French bread-like substitute that is often sold in grocery stores or other parts of the country!

Also available as a Mini Bagel or Flat Bagel!

Details

Boiled, baked 'n shipped fresh from New York City…

  • Shipped to you with free overnight2-Day shipping
  • Large New York City bagels
  • No preservatives of any kind
  • No Saturated fat, No bromated flour
  • Star-K, pas Yisroel Kosher certified
  • Packed in a New Yorker Bagels gift box
  • Add a complimentary gift message

 

Ingredients

Plain Bagels Nutrition

UNBLEACHED UNBROMATED ENRICHED WHEAT FLOUR (WHEAT FLOUR, MALTED BARLEY FLOUR, NIACIN, REDUCED IRON, THIAMINE MONONITRATE, RIBOFLAVIN, FOLIC ACID), WATER, WHOLE WHEAT FLOUR, BROWN SUGAR, MALT SYRUP, CONTAINS 2% OR LESS OF EACH OF THE FOLLOWING: SEA SALT, RAISIN JUICE CONCENTRATE, YEAST, MOLASSES POWDER, ASCORBIC ACID, ENZYMES, CORNMEAL.

Contains: Wheat.
Made in a facility that processes Sesame.


While our bakery does not process milk, eggs or tree nuts, some ingredients may come from facilities that also handle these allergens.

Vegan Statement

None of our bagels contain animal products - they are 100% Vegan.

Subscriptions details
Delivery
Delivery
2-Day shipping included!
Overnight shipping included!
Kosher bagels

Kosher Certified

Seed Oil Free

100% Vegan

Info

While some may think the Plain Bagel is boring, to the purist there is none better. A hand-rolled, fresh plain bagel baked by New Yorker Bagels has some attributes that take it from ordinary to something you absolutely adore sinking your teeth into.

This classic Plain Bagel has a lovely golden crust, shiny and hard on the surface, with a glossy appearance unmarred by any topping. Anything that is added to a plain bagel automatically removes its claim to the name, “plain!”

Our Plain Bagel is just soft enough to tear into with your teeth, the crust giving way to a well-risen inside that is chewy without being tough. This is a real New York bagel, not a soft, French bread-like substitute that is often sold in grocery stores or other parts of the country!

Also available as a Mini Bagel or Flat Bagel!

Details

Boiled, baked 'n shipped fresh from New York City…

  • Shipped to you with free overnight2-Day shipping
  • Large New York City bagels
  • No preservatives of any kind
  • No Saturated fat, No bromated flour
  • Star-K, pas Yisroel Kosher certified
  • Packed in a New Yorker Bagels gift box
  • Add a complimentary gift message

 

Ingredients

Plain Bagels Nutrition

UNBLEACHED UNBROMATED ENRICHED WHEAT FLOUR (WHEAT FLOUR, MALTED BARLEY FLOUR, NIACIN, REDUCED IRON, THIAMINE MONONITRATE, RIBOFLAVIN, FOLIC ACID), WATER, WHOLE WHEAT FLOUR, BROWN SUGAR, MALT SYRUP, CONTAINS 2% OR LESS OF EACH OF THE FOLLOWING: SEA SALT, RAISIN JUICE CONCENTRATE, YEAST, MOLASSES POWDER, ASCORBIC ACID, ENZYMES, CORNMEAL.

Contains: Wheat.
Made in a facility that processes Sesame.


While our bakery does not process milk, eggs or tree nuts, some ingredients may come from facilities that also handle these allergens.

Vegan Statement

None of our bagels contain animal products - they are 100% Vegan.

Reviews
  • 5 stars: 132 (90%)
  • 4 stars: 5 (3%)
  • 3 stars: 7 (5%)
  • 2 stars: 1 (1%)
  • 1 star: 2 (1%)
Some of the reviews shown are from related products the merchant grouped with this one.
E
Elizabeth Dixon (Charlotte, US)
Yummy

These are the best bagels ever

M
Michele Klepac (Belton, US)
Absolutely delicious!!!

Transported back to my childhood in NYC. Love them!

m
mike Skrip (Waterbury, US)

Plain Bagels

E
Elliott Kirkland III (Deale, US)

Plain Bagels

g
glenn moore (Memphis, US)

Obvious different recipe or mix used. Latest order received did not match the first few orders received.

Hi Glenn! Thank you for your review! We’re sorry to hear that you didn’t enjoy your recent order. We use the same old-time recipes from the 1970s and haven’t changed them. We noticed that your recent order was for our large hand-rolled bagels, while your previous orders were for our Mini Bagels. Our Mini Bagels are smaller and denser, similar to the style of bagels traditionally found on New York City’s Lower East Side. Our hand-rolled bagels, on the other hand, are larger and have a more doughy texture. We hope this helps explain the difference between the two styles. Our Customer Service team has already reached out to you directly to assist you further.
New Yorker Bagels

A
Anne Davidson (Coldwater, US)

Pretty darn good bagels

M
Marcia Galindo (Lanham, US)
Delicious!

I’m from Queens…. These are the Real Thing!

T
Thomas Berenson (Broken Arrow, US)
New Yorker Bagels

Nothing taste like a genuine New York bagel. Out here in the wasteland of Oklahoma you cannot get a decent bagel. Sure there are lots of places that bake bagels, but they’re not as good as a genuine New York bagel like we get from New Yorker bagels. I’m a plain bagel kind of guy. I like them that way. I also like the cinnamon raisin bagels. If you want a genuine New York
bagel that tastes like a New York bagel there’s only one place to get them and that’s the big apple. New Yorker bagels you can’t go wrong.

G
Grace 24812 Furst (Miami, US)

Plain Bagels

Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback. Please watch for an email from our
customer service team as we have reached out to you, we would love to learn why you were
only able to leave 3-stars. We value your feedback and share it with our bakers to continuously
improve our products.

B
Barry Barry
they are very good

the way I like them ,nice and chewy.

D
DANIELLE LUNDGREN (Barbourville, US)

Great , ready for my discount, but I can’t find it

D
Denise Gause (New York, US)
A taste of heaven

Absolutely the BEST bagels !! Worth every penny!!!

D
Debra Sander (Seminole, US)

I love your bagels. I just wish you would check off. What is what on the outside of the bag

K
Karen Rodriguez (Inverness, US)
Best bagels

Moved south, couldn’t get a decent bagel. So glad we found you! Definitely like we used to get in NY.

D
David Darrow (Savannah, US)
First time ordering

This was my first order, I brought them to work and everyone raved how good they were. Will definitely be ordering again.

R
Ross Warren (Rupert, US)
Always good...

Always perfect!

D
Diane Lezama (Austin, US)
New York Bagels, three Best

The best bagels and bialys in the country since I left New York City. Impossible to find even “good” bagels let alone great ones… Guess it’s true, it’s the New York water!!!

A
Ann Israel (Hudson, US)

Yum!

S
Susan Bloom (Lancaster, US)
Nothing compares to a New York Bagel!

Yummy! A perfect treat!

L
Louis Clementi (Miami, US)
Plain Bagels

LOVE THEM.
Everyone who tries them , loves them too!!

C
Carmen Trejo (Austin, US)

My bagels came on time and were fresh

L
Lynn Brewer (Concord, US)
My first Purchase

I was looking for great bagels and I found them, you kept me abreast every step of the way even telling me how to freeze and unthaw them. What I couldn't believe what the size and texture of your bagels. I will be a repeat customer. I would love if you carried Caraway seeded bagels?

E
Ellen Koonce (Southern Pines, US)
Great bagels

I left NY 27 years ago and haven't had a decent bagel since. I saw your ad on Facebook and decided to give you a try. Your bagels brought me right back to NY. I have finally found a place to satisfy my cravings! Thank you!

S
Shirley Cribbs (La Grande, US)
First order

I ordered your bagels for the first time and they are without a doubt the best bagels we have ever eaten.. I will be reordering.

N
Nancy Rust (Pensacola, US)
Amazing bagels

OMG! So fresh and delicious. Best ever. Takes me back to NY!

L
Linda crain (Stillwater, US)

Very good

A
Albert Brockly (Morris, US)
Delivery problem

Your delivery service is your only problem

C
Chris Fabel (Thief River Falls, US)
Huge, tasty bagels!

This was my first order, and I'm very impressed! I'll be ordering other flavors soon.

A
Ashley Stewart

Plain Bagels

V
Victor Tognazzini (Somerset, US)

Plain Bagels

D
Diana Erickson (Lakeland, US)
Bagels From Home

So nice to have bagels like home in Florida. Loving them!

T
Trudy Silverman (Tuckahoe, US)
Great!

My good friend in Cincinnati claims no good bagel shops near her (hint) and loves when i send her a surprise from your place!
Thank you for having such quick turn around delivery!

B
Babs (Shrewsbury, US)
Simple Classic

These are so simple and so delicious. They have a great chew and toast very well

new york plain bagel
Plain Bagels
A toasted bagel filled with cream cheese, sliced smoked salmon, red onion and capers on a white plate.

Plain Bagel With Lox and Cream Cheese

The one that started it all...

Ingredients:

  • One fresh, New York City plain bagel
  • 2 - 2.5 oz. plain cream cheese (scallion or chive cream cheese can also be used)
  • 2 - 3 oz. cold smoked salmon or lox (about 2 thick slices)
  • 1 tablespoon capers
  • ¼ - ½ of a red onion, sliced thin
  • Optional: 3-4 thin cucumber slices

Steps:

  1. Slice a New Yorker Plain bagel in half and lightly toast.
  2. Schmear a thick layer of cream cheese on both sides. Use your preferred cream cheese - plain or flavored work fine!
  3. Layer the salmon slices over one side of the bagel.
  4. Scatter red onion slices over the salmon.
  5. Top with a few capers.

Options: 

  • Add a few cucumber slices too.
  • Add a squeeze of fresh lemon juice.
  • Top with cracked black pepper.

Fresh Bagel Questions

Also see our Ordering & Shipping Help page for detailed information.

Info

While some may think the Plain Bagel is boring, to the purist there is none better. A hand-rolled, fresh plain bagel baked by New Yorker Bagels has some attributes that take it from ordinary to something you absolutely adore sinking your teeth into.

This classic Plain Bagel has a lovely golden crust, shiny and hard on the surface, with a glossy appearance unmarred by any topping. Anything that is added to a plain bagel automatically removes its claim to the name, “plain!”

Our Plain Bagel is just soft enough to tear into with your teeth, the crust giving way to a well-risen inside that is chewy without being tough. This is a real New York bagel, not a soft, French bread-like substitute that is often sold in grocery stores or other parts of the country!

Also available as a Mini Bagel or Flat Bagel!

Details

Boiled, baked 'n shipped fresh from New York City…

  • Shipped to you with free overnight2-Day shipping
  • Large New York City bagels
  • No preservatives of any kind
  • No Saturated fat, No bromated flour
  • Star-K, pas Yisroel Kosher certified
  • Packed in a New Yorker Bagels gift box
  • Add a complimentary gift message

 

Ingredients

Plain Bagels Nutrition

UNBLEACHED UNBROMATED ENRICHED WHEAT FLOUR (WHEAT FLOUR, MALTED BARLEY FLOUR, NIACIN, REDUCED IRON, THIAMINE MONONITRATE, RIBOFLAVIN, FOLIC ACID), WATER, WHOLE WHEAT FLOUR, BROWN SUGAR, MALT SYRUP, CONTAINS 2% OR LESS OF EACH OF THE FOLLOWING: SEA SALT, RAISIN JUICE CONCENTRATE, YEAST, MOLASSES POWDER, ASCORBIC ACID, ENZYMES, CORNMEAL.

Contains: Wheat.
Made in a facility that processes Sesame.


While our bakery does not process milk, eggs or tree nuts, some ingredients may come from facilities that also handle these allergens.

Vegan Statement

None of our bagels contain animal products - they are 100% Vegan.

Reviews