As the bakers of more than 50% of all fresh bagels eaten in New York City every day, we know a thing or two about bagel flavors and varieties! In fact, we're proud to offer 22 different full-size bagel flavor options (plus 8 mini bagel flavors too!)
Here's a rundown of our most Unique Bagel Flavors
Best Bagels for Kids
Have a picky eater in the family? We gotchya! Kids can't resist the delicious texture of a real bagel's crust coupled wit a touch of sweetness. Here are the 3 best bagels for kids.
French Toast Bagels
Often imitated, we actually invented the French Toast Bagel – back in the mid 80's. The sweet 'n savory aroma of cinnamon fills the room upon toasting, and is beautifully complemented with a dab of creamy butter.
Rainbow Bagels
Of course a real Rainbow Bagel looks great, but we go a step further: adding tasty morsels of real fruit in ours, giving kids yummy, chewy tang of fruit with almost every bite.
Blueberry Bagels
To a bagel purist, this flavor is a blasphemy. We get it. Yet toasted Blueberry bagels happen to be delicious. Try toasted with schmear of quality butter.
Exotic Bagels
Wanna push the envelope? Open your mind - and your mouth😀 - to our avant garde, exotic bagel options. We find many of these work best for lunch, as the platform for a truly stellar sandwich.
Jalapeño Red Pepper Bagels
Our spicy little friend keeps growing in popularity. Try it with sliced chicken or turkey breast plus your favorite cheese.
Kalamata Olive Bagels
A dark-horse sandwich all-star. Don't be afraid! Imported Greek olives make it the perfect accompaniment to anything Mediterranean. Try it with cheese and ripe tomato, or toast with a little extra-virgin olive oil.
Marble Rye Bagels
Inspired by one of our favorite Seinfeld episode. For those in-the-know, this beautiful bagel has become the go-to for a perfect Reuben sandwich. Sony Pictures hasn't sued us yet😅
Pumpernickel Bagels
Now we're kicking it old-school. But with age comes wisdom. if you're looking for a unique bagel option, why not look back instead of into the future? A pumpernickel bagel tastes noticeably more complex and savory — darker, earthier, and a bit more assertive.
Healthy Bagels
Cranberry Energy Bagels
One of the newest additions to exotic bagel offerings, this bagel is loaded with tangy dried cranberries, and topped with healthy quinoa and seeds. It uses a multi-grain flour instead of white, so if offers significant fiber and long-term energy.
Quinoa Multigrain Bagels
Another yummy whole grain bagel option, the delightful crunch of real quinoa gives every bite a 'lil pop. Toast and top with olive oil for a truly healthful treat!
Whole Wheat Everything Bagels
The PERFECT way to get some healthy whole grains into any picky eater... The savory Everything toppings completely obscure that you're enjoying a healthy, whole wheat product. You sneaky devil, you!