Enjoy FREE Overnight Shipping*! Order now.

Enjoy FREE Overnight Shipping*! Order now.

Drop your flavor here
$99.00 $94.00

Custom Box, 3 Dozen Bagels + Spreads

Create your custom box! Select 6 bagel flavors

1
Pack 1

2
Pack 2

3
Pack 3

4
Pack 4

5
Pack 5

6
Pack 6

apple bagel

Apple Cinnamon

blueberry bagels

Blueberry

Cinnamon Raisin Bagels

Cinnamon Raisin

healthy bagel

Cranberry Energy

fresh egg bagel

Egg

egg everything bagels

Egg Everything

real everything bagels

Everything

french toast bagel

French Toast

garlic bagels

Garlic

jalapeño bagels

Jalapeño Red Pepper

olive bagel

Kalamata Olive

rye bagel

Marble Rye

fresh onion bagel

Onion

new york plain bagel

Plain

poppyseed bagels

Poppy

pumpernickel bagel

Pumpernickel

healthiest bagel

Quinoa Multigrain

order rainbow bagels

Rainbow

order sesame bagels

Sesame

fresh whole what bagels

Whole Wheat

whole wheat bagels

Whole Wheat Everything

fresh bialys

Bialys

Create your own assortment! Select 6 bagel varieties and we include 36 yummy packets to top them!

Complete bagel party! Save big on 36 hand-rolled New York City bagels, shipped with delicious topping packets for a turnkey breakfast, brunch or snack. 

Chocolate Hazelnut Spread:  An exceptional nutty and smooth chocolate experience. 25% less sugar than the leading brand.

Raspberry Jam Spread: Slow cooked farm-fresh raspberries plus a subtle sweetness.

Almond Spread - California almonds with just the right amount of cane sugar for a delicious, sweet almond experience.

Note: This package includes options to order Everything, Onion or Garlic bagels or Bialys. The intense garlic or onion aroma of these flavors may adhere slightly to flavors during shipping. 

Details

Bagels

  • 3 dozen fresh, hand-rolled, large NYC bagels: Packed as 6 sleeves of 6
  • Shipped fresh to you with overnight shipping included
  • No preservatives of any kind
  • No bromated flour; No Saturated fat or Trans fat
  • Certified Star-K Kosher
  • Hand rolled and packed in a New Yorker Bagels gift box; Add a complimentary gift message

Spread Packets

  • 36 individual Spread Delight packets to top our bagels (12 of each: Almond, Chocolate Hazelnut and Raspberry Jam)
  • All Natural; No high fructose corn syrup or preservatives. Made in the USA.
  • Non-GMO; Sustainably Sourced Palm Oil
Ingredients

 

Allergen Statement - Bagels

New Yorker Bagels is not a certified nut free environment, although none of our products contain any nuts. Residual nut contamination from our ingredient supplies is possible, though unlikely. 

The only common allergens that are present in our products are wheat, soy and sesame. All of our bagels contain wheat and soy. Please see ingredient lists below for information on a specific bagel flavor.

Allergen Statement - Spreads

The product inside these sealed spread packets care produced in a facility where wheat, milk, tree nuts, eggs and soy are used. Chocolate Hazelnut and Almond spreads contain nuts, but no peanuts.

Vegan Statement

None of our bagels contain animal products with the exception of natural honey. Some items contain honey.

Create your own assortment! Select 6 bagel varieties and we include 36 yummy packets to top them!

Complete bagel party! Save big on 36 hand-rolled New York City bagels, shipped with delicious topping packets for a turnkey breakfast, brunch or snack. 

Chocolate Hazelnut Spread:  An exceptional nutty and smooth chocolate experience. 25% less sugar than the leading brand.

Raspberry Jam Spread: Slow cooked farm-fresh raspberries plus a subtle sweetness.

Almond Spread - California almonds with just the right amount of cane sugar for a delicious, sweet almond experience.

Note: This package includes options to order Everything, Onion or Garlic bagels or Bialys. The intense garlic or onion aroma of these flavors may adhere slightly to flavors during shipping. 

Details

Bagels

  • 3 dozen fresh, hand-rolled, large NYC bagels: Packed as 6 sleeves of 6
  • Shipped fresh to you with overnight shipping included
  • No preservatives of any kind
  • No bromated flour; No Saturated fat or Trans fat
  • Certified Star-K Kosher
  • Hand rolled and packed in a New Yorker Bagels gift box; Add a complimentary gift message

Spread Packets

  • 36 individual Spread Delight packets to top our bagels (12 of each: Almond, Chocolate Hazelnut and Raspberry Jam)
  • All Natural; No high fructose corn syrup or preservatives. Made in the USA.
  • Non-GMO; Sustainably Sourced Palm Oil
Ingredients

 

Allergen Statement - Bagels

New Yorker Bagels is not a certified nut free environment, although none of our products contain any nuts. Residual nut contamination from our ingredient supplies is possible, though unlikely. 

The only common allergens that are present in our products are wheat, soy and sesame. All of our bagels contain wheat and soy. Please see ingredient lists below for information on a specific bagel flavor.

Allergen Statement - Spreads

The product inside these sealed spread packets care produced in a facility where wheat, milk, tree nuts, eggs and soy are used. Chocolate Hazelnut and Almond spreads contain nuts, but no peanuts.

Vegan Statement

None of our bagels contain animal products with the exception of natural honey. Some items contain honey.

Customer Reviews

Based on 23 reviews
96%
(22)
4%
(1)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
A
Audrey Hetelson
Wonderful

My son received these bagels as a gift for his birthday and he said "The bagels are great and heat up really well.

C
Cece Mees
The BEST ever!

Sent the bagels to my niece in Virginia at her workplace for her birthday and staff were delighted and grateful.

M
Martha Wilson
YUM

Fast shipping, and worth it. So good! The spreads are also delicious!

J
Josie Vranick

Best bagels I’ve ordered online! Delivered fresh & delicious!

A
Ann Hein
Always delicious!

My bagels arrived on time and were delicious and fresh…of course I’ll order again!

j
joe mccurry
It's been many years

It's been several years since I've had a really good bagel. I thoroughly enjoyed the ones I've had so far and following your instructions for the storage hope to make them last.

D
Dave Wohl

3 Dozen Bagels + Spreads

Create your own assortment! Select 6 bagel varieties and we include 36 yummy packets to top them!

Complete bagel party! Save big on 36 hand-rolled New York City bagels, shipped with delicious topping packets for a turnkey breakfast, brunch or snack. 

Chocolate Hazelnut Spread:  An exceptional nutty and smooth chocolate experience. 25% less sugar than the leading brand.

Raspberry Jam Spread: Slow cooked farm-fresh raspberries plus a subtle sweetness.

Almond Spread - California almonds with just the right amount of cane sugar for a delicious, sweet almond experience.

Note: This package includes options to order Everything, Onion or Garlic bagels or Bialys. The intense garlic or onion aroma of these flavors may adhere slightly to flavors during shipping. 

Details

Bagels

  • 3 dozen fresh, hand-rolled, large NYC bagels: Packed as 6 sleeves of 6
  • Shipped fresh to you with overnight shipping included
  • No preservatives of any kind
  • No bromated flour; No Saturated fat or Trans fat
  • Certified Star-K Kosher
  • Hand rolled and packed in a New Yorker Bagels gift box; Add a complimentary gift message

Spread Packets

  • 36 individual Spread Delight packets to top our bagels (12 of each: Almond, Chocolate Hazelnut and Raspberry Jam)
  • All Natural; No high fructose corn syrup or preservatives. Made in the USA.
  • Non-GMO; Sustainably Sourced Palm Oil
Ingredients

 

Allergen Statement - Bagels

New Yorker Bagels is not a certified nut free environment, although none of our products contain any nuts. Residual nut contamination from our ingredient supplies is possible, though unlikely. 

The only common allergens that are present in our products are wheat, soy and sesame. All of our bagels contain wheat and soy. Please see ingredient lists below for information on a specific bagel flavor.

Allergen Statement - Spreads

The product inside these sealed spread packets care produced in a facility where wheat, milk, tree nuts, eggs and soy are used. Chocolate Hazelnut and Almond spreads contain nuts, but no peanuts.

Vegan Statement

None of our bagels contain animal products with the exception of natural honey. Some items contain honey.

Customer Reviews

Based on 23 reviews
96%
(22)
4%
(1)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
A
Audrey Hetelson
Wonderful

My son received these bagels as a gift for his birthday and he said "The bagels are great and heat up really well.

C
Cece Mees
The BEST ever!

Sent the bagels to my niece in Virginia at her workplace for her birthday and staff were delighted and grateful.

M
Martha Wilson
YUM

Fast shipping, and worth it. So good! The spreads are also delicious!

J
Josie Vranick

Best bagels I’ve ordered online! Delivered fresh & delicious!

A
Ann Hein
Always delicious!

My bagels arrived on time and were delicious and fresh…of course I’ll order again!

j
joe mccurry
It's been many years

It's been several years since I've had a really good bagel. I thoroughly enjoyed the ones I've had so far and following your instructions for the storage hope to make them last.

D
Dave Wohl

3 Dozen Bagels + Spreads

Select your delivery