FREE 2-Day Shipping from NYC! Order now

FREE 2-Day Shipping from NYC! Order now

New York Bagels Gourmet Gift Shop

Surprise and delight with an impressive gift box of hand-rolled NYC bagels!
Hand-rolled in New York City. Free 2-day Shipping.

Gourmet New York Bagel Gifts

Surprise and delight with a gift box of hand-rolled NYC bagels. Add a Gift Note.
Express Shipping Included.

Red-Swirled Christmas Bagels

Available for a short time only! Our hand-rolled plain NYC bagels with a special red-swirl added to the dough.
Free Overnight Shipping.

$39.50

the-new-yorker-4-bagel-classics-bagels-730_928x928__PID:055f575a-b702-45ee-a36b-f1f712bfab26

The New Yorker - 2 Dozen

Delight with our 4 top selling hand-rolled bagels:
Cinnamon Raisin, Everything, Plain and Sesame.

Delight with our four top selling hand-rolled bagels: Cinnamon Raisin, Everything, Plain and Sesame.

$42 $59

the-astoria-2-dozen-bagels-994_928x928__PID:ac6745f1-dafc-457d-9d87-d14a4a9cb3b4

The Astoria - 2 Dozen

A gift to mix it up! Includes Everything, Poppy,
plus two exclusives: French Toast and Jalapeño Red Pepper.

A gift to mix it up! Includes Everything, Poppy, plus two exclusives: French Toast and Jalapeño Red Pepper.

$42  $59

Product Details

send a box of ny bagels

1 Dozen Custom Box

Select two hand-rolled New York City varieties.

$29.50

bagels with mikes hot honey

1 Dozen + Spreads

Select two hand-rolled, and we add yummy spreads to top 'em!

$42.50 $49

3 dozen bagels with toppings

3 Dozen + Spreads

Select six hand-rolled New York City bagel varieties.
We'll include spread packettes for a complete package.

Select six hand-rolled New York City bagel varieties. We'll include spread packettes for a complete package.

$74.95  $98

BUILD YOUR BOX!
bagel of the month

Bagel of the Month - 3 Months

Send 3 months of fresh, hand-rolled NYC bagels.
Automatically baked & shipped each month.

Send 3 months of fresh, hand-rolled NYC bagels. Automatically baked and shipped each month.

$88 $118

send Bagel of the Month

Bagel of the Month - 6 Months

Send 6 months of fresh, hand-rolled NYC bagels.
Automatically baked and shipped each month.

Send 6 months of fresh, hand-rolled NYC bagels. Automatically baked and shipped each month.

$177 $237

bagel of the month gourmet gift

Bagel of the Month - 12 Months

Amaze with a full year of fresh, hand-rolled NYC bagels.
Automatically baked and shipped each month.

Amaze with a full year of fresh, hand-rolled NYC bagels. Automatically baked and shipped each month.

$355 $474

bagel gift card

Fresh New York Bagel Gift Cards

Not sure when they'll be home?
You can still send authentic, fresh NY bagels with an e-gift card.
We email these, so you can print out or just forward away! 

$25 - $200

Need to send a lotta gifts? Corporate gifts?
Contact Us for our corporate order form.
Just send us your list and we'll take care of everything!

Need to send a lotta gifts?
Corporate gifts?

Contact us
for our corporate order form. Just send us your list and we'll take care of everything!

bagels for Hanukkahfresh bagels gift

What do New Yorkers think of our hand-rolled bagels?

All of our bagels:

  • Rolled by Hand in New York City
  • Shipped fresh - 2-day shipping included
  • No preservatives of any kind
  • Star-K, pas Yisroel Kosher certified
  • Packed in a New Yorker Bagels gift box
  • Add a gift message

All of our bagels:

  • Rolled By Hand in New York City
  • Shipped fresh - 2-day or Overnight
  • No preservatives of any kind
  • Certified Star-K pas Yisroel Kosher
  • Packed in a New Yorker Bagels gift box
  • Add a gift message



Stay fresh! Follow us:
Facebook Instagram Pinterest Twitter