Free FedEx Standard Overnight Shipping.

New Yorker Bagels

NYC Bagel Club

We're pleased to introduce offer NYC Bagel Subscription Club. With this feature, you can now easily get fresh, hand-rolled New York City bagels delivered automatically, at nearly any interval you choose. Update: we now have over 1,500 Bagel Club members!

bagel of the monthTo keep this program simple, we've added the ability to "subscribe" to almost any product on our website! You can set automated deliveries for a Specific Bagel Flavor or a curated Box Set

New! By popular demand, you can now also subscribe to a Custom  Box - and change flavors between your automatic orders! Click here to sign up.

When you subscribe you save an additional 7%, in addition to the free overnight shipping we provide.

To join 'da club:


1) Select the product you'd like to subscribe to on our website.

2) Click the "Subscribe & Save" button on that product page:

3) Select whether you want to subscribe on a WEEKLY or MONTHLY basis:

NYC bagel subscription

4) Set the INTERVAL for the Week or Month:

bagel club 

5) Click our "Add to Bagel Cart" button and check out normally.

That's it! We'll send you an email each time a new shipment is about to be rolled, baked and shipped to you. You can easily manage your NYC Bagel Club account by logging in (an email with a link will be sent to you). you can pause, change or cancel your Bagel Club subscription anytime. 


For our Custom Box of 12, the NYC Bagel Club subscription is handled differently, due to the complex nature of allowing customers to swap flavors between their Custom Box orders.

To sign up for a Custom Subscription:

For help and details on subscribing to and managing a Custom Box, see the help page


You can also prepay a 3, 6 or 12 month hand-rolled Bagel-of-the-Month Subscription for someone else, on this page!


Please login to your account at to pause, edit or change date of your next shipment!

Bagel Subscription Club Notes: 

We look forward to servicing you. Thanks!