Hand-rolled Bagel Gift Boxes
Hand-rolled Fresh Bagel Gift Boxes
Fresh from NYC with free 2-Day shipping
STAR-K KOSHER 🔸 ADD A GIFT MESSAGE
Fresh 'n fast with free 2-Day shipping
HAND-ROLLED IN NYC 🥯 SHIPPED FRESH 🥯 STAR-K KOSHER
Need to send a lotta gifts? Corporate gifts?
Ship multiple gifts by placing just
Need to send a lotta gifts? Corporate gifts?
Ship multiple gifts by placing just one order!
Shop Multi-GiftingFresh Bagels from New York City
Free 2-Day Shipping
Surprise and delight with a gift box of hand-rolled NYC bagels. Add a Gift Note.
Express Shipping Included.
Red-Swirled Christmas Bagels
Available for a short time only! Our hand-rolled plain NYC bagels with a special red-swirl added to the dough.
Free Overnight Shipping.
$39.50
NYC Bagel Gift Boxes
The Astoria
A gift to mix it up! Includes 2 exclusives: French Toast and Jalapeño Red Pepper.
A gift to mix it up! Includes Everything, Poppy, plus two exclusives: French Toast and Jalapeño Red Pepper.
$44 - $59
Custom Box - 2 Dozen
You select 4 of our 22 available varieties to send to someone special!
A gift to mix it up! Includes Everything, Poppy, plus two exclusives: French Toast and Jalapeño Red Pepper.
$44
Fresh Bagels with Spreads
The New Yorker + Spreads
All-time best selling fresh NYC bagels. We add yummy spreads to top 'em!
$62 - $86.75
2 Dozen + Spreads
Select 4 varieties to send, We add 24 yummy packets to top 'em all!
$62
Fresh Bagels with Coffee
The New Yorker + Coffee
Most popular New York Bagels paired with our premium instant coffees.
$64 - $89.75
2 Dozen + Coffee
Select 4 New York bagel varieties and we add coffees to pair 'em.
$64
Fresh Bagels with Spreads & Coffee
The New Yorker + Spreads + Coffee
Best selling NYC bagels with spreads and coffee for a complete package!
$92 - $116.75
2 Dozen + Spreads + Coffee
Select 4 varieties and we'll add yummy spreads and coffee too!
$92
Bagel of the Month Gifts
Free 2-Day Shipping Each Month!
↓
Fresh Bagel Gift Cards
Let customers speak for us
I have ordered from here a few times typically sticking with the plain and everything. They are so delicious and equally as good after frozen. Highly recommend!
Quick delivery. Great fresh bagels.
Nothing like a New York bagel! Delicious!
Bought the classics and absolutely hands down these are the best bagels I’ve ever eaten/purchased. Buy them! You won’t regret it! Absolutely yummy! Worth every penny! Oops nickel! Gov doesn’t make a penny anymore lol.
The best I have been able to find. Price is good and shipping fast. Have purchased several times.
For quality, flavor and richness these bagels cannot be beat. No how, no way- simply the best!
Was so happy to find out you made pumpkin bagels in the fall! They are absolutely delicious and I just ordered more to keep my freezer stocked through the winter.
I LOVE these! Each bagel is a good size. Toasted they are great balance of crunchy on outside and softbon inside. I really like all the colors.
Because I love all of the regular sized bagels, the mini’s do not disappoint! They are just smaller in size, however, the flavor is as big and yummy as the full-sized bagels!
LOVE,LOVE LOVE NEW YORK BAGELS!!!LOVE NEW YORK!!!!LOVE THE YANKEE’S!!!!
No lie. These are the best I’ve ever had.
Living in Florida is lovely but a decent bagel, especially poppy seed, is a bagel wasteland for this transplanted Philly girl. I finally bit the bullet and ordered bagels from you (and bialys for my hubby) and I am not disappointed.
They are big and crusty on the outside and soft on the inside. I especially like the free shipping. You will continue to get orders from me in the future.
5 yrs after relocating from NJ to EAST TENNESSEE i had lost hope of finding a real bagel in TENNESSEE then i thought “could there possibly be a bagel store where they could possibly SHIP me a bagel? Or possibly 2-3 DOZEN? Well this is my 3rd order and I can’t stress enough when i say “keep the bagels coming” and “THANK YOU”
These made-to-order bagels are the very best. I highly recommend them.
2nd order. Huge bagels with huge flavor. Especially like the consistency of the center. Not too heavy.
Need to send a lotta gifts? Corporate gifts?
Use our new multi-gifting service to send multiple boxes by placing just one order!
Shop Multi-GiftingFrom the World's Largest Fresh Bagel Bakery.
Learn More About Us:
Need to send a lotta gifts?
Corporate gifts?
Contact us for our corporate order form. Just send us your list and we'll take care of everything!
What do New Yorkers think of our hand-rolled bagels?
