Enjoy FREE Overnight Shipping*! Order now.

Enjoy FREE Overnight Shipping*! Order now.

Unique Gifts of New York Bagels

Unique Gifts

Fresh, Hand-Rolled New York City Bagels

Shipped Fresh in a Gift Box with Overnight Shipping Included  ~  Add a Gift Note

Bagel Gift

1 Dozen NYC Bagel Gift Box

Send an impressive gift box of hand-rolled NYC bagels to someone special! You choose 4 different flavors from our available 22 varieties. Free overnight shipping.


bagel of the month

Bagel-of-the-Month Gift

A gift of freshness that keeps giving, includes the most popular bagels: Your recipient will be sent Plain, Sesame, Poppy & Cinnamon Raisin bagels each month. Free overnight shipping.

starts at $112

Bagels with Spreads

1 Dozen Box with Spreads

You choose 4 different hand-rolled NYC bagel flavors and we add 12 spread packettes to top 'em! An impressive gift box filled with fresh New York City Bagels. Free overnight shipping.


3 Dozen Box with Spreads

Create an incredible assortment by selecting 6 hand-rolled flavors, and save big-time (vs. 1 dozen) on 36 hand-rolled NYC bagels + 36 packettes. Free overnight shipping.


Bagels with Spreads

Mini Bagel-of-the-Month

These kettle-boiled mini bagels are sent in 3 popular flavors: Plain, Sesame and Everything. Free overnight shipping.

Starts at $112.60


Fresh NYC Gift Cards

Shopping for someone else but not sure what to give? Just send the gift of hand-rolledness! We email these, so you can print out or just forward away!

$25 - $200


What do New Yorkers think of our hand-rolled bagels?

   All of Our Bagels:
  • Rolled By Hand in New York City
  • Shipped fresh with Standard Overnight FedEx shipping included
  • No preservatives of any kind; No bromates or bromated flour
  • No Saturated fat or Trans fat
  • Certified Star-K Kosher
  • Packed in a New Yorker Bagels gift box
  • Add a free complimentary gift message if you wish

Stay fresh! Follow us:
Facebook Instagram Pinterest Twitter

new york bagels