Free 2-Day shipping from NYC! Order
Free 2-Day shipping from NYC! Order
A New York egg bagel is a bit richer than a standard plain bagel, and appeals to folks for whom a plain bagel is just too, well, plain. A New Yorker Bagels Egg bagel can be eaten fresh and hot with nothing on it, split for a sandwich, or halved and toasted for munching.
You get 2 dozen fresh, hand-rolled NYC bagels, shipped fresh to you with free 2-day shipping. No preservatives of any kind, no Saturated fat or Trans fat, plus Star-K, pas Yisroel Kosher certified.
Always great and fresh!
Love these Bagels.
Can't wait for my next order to arrive.
Best I've eaten in a long time
ABSOLUTELY HEAVENLY!!!! My new "comfort food" Every morning I travel back in time!!! Finally A TRUE New York Bagel!!!
30 years in the Midwest and the comment from EVERY bagel shop/deli was always "never heard of egg bagels". IT'S SO GOOD TO HAVE THEM BACK!!! When I found New York Bagel I took a chance hoping they were the Real deal and am thrilled! So much so, I've put in a regular subscription. Thanks for giving me SUCH a good memory back
Followed instruction and they were as advertised.
Buyer be ware. I ordered what was said to be GF bagels and they AREN"T. Even due to their mistake, they refused to credit me the amount I paid. Talk about throwing money away! BAD BAD CUSTOMER SERVICE!!!!
We’d like to clarify that New Yorker Bagels does not — and has never — offered gluten-free bagels. All of our products contain wheat, which is listed on every product page. If our website search results caused any confusion, we sincerely apologize — we’ve since added a clear-er notice stating that all of our products contain gluten.
Though the order was fulfilled correctly based on the items purchased, our team already addressed this matter directly and issued a courtesy partial refund. We are sorry for any misunderstanding caused!
— The New Yorker Bagels Team
Always great and fresh!
Love these Bagels.
Can't wait for my next order to arrive.
Best I've eaten in a long time
ABSOLUTELY HEAVENLY!!!! My new "comfort food" Every morning I travel back in time!!! Finally A TRUE New York Bagel!!!
30 years in the Midwest and the comment from EVERY bagel shop/deli was always "never heard of egg bagels". IT'S SO GOOD TO HAVE THEM BACK!!! When I found New York Bagel I took a chance hoping they were the Real deal and am thrilled! So much so, I've put in a regular subscription. Thanks for giving me SUCH a good memory back
Followed instruction and they were as advertised.
Buyer be ware. I ordered what was said to be GF bagels and they AREN"T. Even due to their mistake, they refused to credit me the amount I paid. Talk about throwing money away! BAD BAD CUSTOMER SERVICE!!!!
We’d like to clarify that New Yorker Bagels does not — and has never — offered gluten-free bagels. All of our products contain wheat, which is listed on every product page. If our website search results caused any confusion, we sincerely apologize — we’ve since added a clear-er notice stating that all of our products contain gluten.
Though the order was fulfilled correctly based on the items purchased, our team already addressed this matter directly and issued a courtesy partial refund. We are sorry for any misunderstanding caused!
— The New Yorker Bagels Team
Copyright © 2026 New Yorker Bagels.
A New York egg bagel is a bit richer than a standard plain bagel, and appeals to folks for whom a plain bagel is just too, well, plain. A New Yorker Bagels Egg bagel can be eaten fresh and hot with nothing on it, split for a sandwich, or halved and toasted for munching.
You get 2 dozen fresh, hand-rolled NYC bagels, shipped fresh to you with free 2-day shipping. No preservatives of any kind, no Saturated fat or Trans fat, plus Star-K, pas Yisroel Kosher certified.
Always great and fresh!
Love these Bagels.
Can't wait for my next order to arrive.
Best I've eaten in a long time
ABSOLUTELY HEAVENLY!!!! My new "comfort food" Every morning I travel back in time!!! Finally A TRUE New York Bagel!!!
30 years in the Midwest and the comment from EVERY bagel shop/deli was always "never heard of egg bagels". IT'S SO GOOD TO HAVE THEM BACK!!! When I found New York Bagel I took a chance hoping they were the Real deal and am thrilled! So much so, I've put in a regular subscription. Thanks for giving me SUCH a good memory back
Followed instruction and they were as advertised.
Buyer be ware. I ordered what was said to be GF bagels and they AREN"T. Even due to their mistake, they refused to credit me the amount I paid. Talk about throwing money away! BAD BAD CUSTOMER SERVICE!!!!
We’d like to clarify that New Yorker Bagels does not — and has never — offered gluten-free bagels. All of our products contain wheat, which is listed on every product page. If our website search results caused any confusion, we sincerely apologize — we’ve since added a clear-er notice stating that all of our products contain gluten.
Though the order was fulfilled correctly based on the items purchased, our team already addressed this matter directly and issued a courtesy partial refund. We are sorry for any misunderstanding caused!
— The New Yorker Bagels Team