Free 2-Day shipping from NYC! Order
Free 2-Day shipping from NYC! Order
The classic Pumpernickel Bagel may get overlooked because no one is quite sure what goes well with it. The simple answer is, everything goes well with our savory pumpernickel!
If you enjoy a topping on any other bagel, odds are you will like it on a Pumpernickel too! That said, there are some time-tested toppings that can take a tasty plain New Yorker Pumpernickel Bagel to a new level of flavor.


UNBLEACHED UNBROMATED ENRICHED WHEAT FLOUR (WHEAT FLOUR, MALTED BARLEY FLOUR, NIACIN, REDUCED IRON, THIAMINE MONONITRATE, RIBOFLAVIN, FOLIC ACID), WATER, RYE PUMPERNICKEL FLOUR, BROWN SUGAR, MALT SYRUP, CONTAINS 2% OR LESS OF EACH OF THE FOLLOWING: CARAMEL COLOR, SEA SALT, CARAWAY SEEDS, RAISIN JUICE CONCENTRATE, YEAST, MALT POWDER, MOLASSES POWDER, SOYBEAN OIL, WHEAT GLUTEN, ASCORBIC ACID, ENZYMES.
Contains: Wheat.
While our bakery does not process milk, eggs or tree nuts, some ingredients may come from facilities that also handle these allergens.
None of our bagels contain animal products - they are 100% Vegan.
Best bagels ever!
There’s nothing as wonderful on this earth as a pumpernickel bagel from New York City.
I’m was worried about the 2 day shipping. How could a bagel be fresh after 2 days in the air?
Well. I don’t know about the science of it but they were perfect. I kept 2 out of the bag and froze the rest of the dozen immediately. So yummy and fresh. My hubby agreed!
My parents absolutely loved them! My father doesn’t want material possessions anymore for gifts so this was perfect. Thank you!
Yummy
Yums!
Bagels are to puffy plus I don’t really get the pumpernickel taste. Goldsteins bagels from Pasadena, ca. are the real thing. They are no longer open
Dear Margaret,
Thank you for taking the time to share your thoughts with us. We’re sorry to hear that the bagels didn’t meet your expectations. Some customers prefer our New York Mini Bagels, which are smaller and denser–like the bagels that were often found in the Lower East Side of New York City. Please watch for an email from our customer service team, as we’ve reached out to see how we can make this right for you.
Copyright © 2026 New Yorker Bagels.
The classic Pumpernickel Bagel may get overlooked because no one is quite sure what goes well with it. The simple answer is, everything goes well with our savory pumpernickel!
If you enjoy a topping on any other bagel, odds are you will like it on a Pumpernickel too! That said, there are some time-tested toppings that can take a tasty plain New Yorker Pumpernickel Bagel to a new level of flavor.


UNBLEACHED UNBROMATED ENRICHED WHEAT FLOUR (WHEAT FLOUR, MALTED BARLEY FLOUR, NIACIN, REDUCED IRON, THIAMINE MONONITRATE, RIBOFLAVIN, FOLIC ACID), WATER, RYE PUMPERNICKEL FLOUR, BROWN SUGAR, MALT SYRUP, CONTAINS 2% OR LESS OF EACH OF THE FOLLOWING: CARAMEL COLOR, SEA SALT, CARAWAY SEEDS, RAISIN JUICE CONCENTRATE, YEAST, MALT POWDER, MOLASSES POWDER, SOYBEAN OIL, WHEAT GLUTEN, ASCORBIC ACID, ENZYMES.
Contains: Wheat.
While our bakery does not process milk, eggs or tree nuts, some ingredients may come from facilities that also handle these allergens.
None of our bagels contain animal products - they are 100% Vegan.
Best bagels ever!
There’s nothing as wonderful on this earth as a pumpernickel bagel from New York City.
I’m was worried about the 2 day shipping. How could a bagel be fresh after 2 days in the air?
Well. I don’t know about the science of it but they were perfect. I kept 2 out of the bag and froze the rest of the dozen immediately. So yummy and fresh. My hubby agreed!
My parents absolutely loved them! My father doesn’t want material possessions anymore for gifts so this was perfect. Thank you!
Yummy
Yums!
Bagels are to puffy plus I don’t really get the pumpernickel taste. Goldsteins bagels from Pasadena, ca. are the real thing. They are no longer open
Dear Margaret,
Thank you for taking the time to share your thoughts with us. We’re sorry to hear that the bagels didn’t meet your expectations. Some customers prefer our New York Mini Bagels, which are smaller and denser–like the bagels that were often found in the Lower East Side of New York City. Please watch for an email from our customer service team, as we’ve reached out to see how we can make this right for you.