Skip to content

Bagel Cart

There are no fresh, yummy bagels in your cart right now ☹️

Article: Ten Bagel Toppings that Shouldn’t Work – But Somehow Do

bagel toppings

Ten Bagel Toppings that Shouldn’t Work – But Somehow Do

Everybody loves a good bagel with cream cheese. While your local bakery or cafe offers a variety of yummy bagel flavors, there are plenty of ways to add some flare to your bagels at home. Here’s a list of some strange, although delicious bagel topping combinations to try.

  • Hot Guac Bagel – Skip the cream cheese and smear guacamole on your toasted bagel. Top if off with a few Flamin’ Hot Cheetos™ for an extra kick of spicy flavor.
  • Truck Stop Bagel – Need an extra dose of protein on your bagel? Try adding some beef jerky and roasted peanuts on top of your cream cheese to create a savory and creamy combination of flavors.
  • The Ritz – Instead of the standard cream cheese, substitute pimiento cheese and top with a few crushed Ritz crackers and a dash of hot sauce.
  • Onion Lover – Start with a toasted onion bagel and smear on a bit of ranch flavored dip. Cover the ranch dip with some crushed Funions™ for a delicious snack.
  • Nacho Average Bagel – If you’re in the mood for something with a bit of a kick, top a bagel with queso dip and add jalapenos and crushed Fritos. Including a dash of hot sauce will put this one over the top.

Not in the mood for spicy or salty? Craving something a bit on the sweeter side? Here are a few suggestions ranging from a hint of sweetness to a complete sugar overload.

  • Peanut Butter and Jam – Start with some raspberry jam on a toasted bagel. Add a bit of peanut butter cereal and top it all off with Reece’s Pieces candies.
  • Peanut Butter Puff – Sticking with the peanut butter theme, adding some Cocoa Puffs cereal to a bagel smeared with peanut butter is simple and satisfies a sweet tooth.
  • Fudge Sundae Bagel – If you’re craving a ton of sugar with a classic flavor, try a fudge sundae bagel. Spread cool whip on a bagel and decorate with roasted peanuts and maraschino cherries. Garnish with some rainbow sprinkles and hot fudge sauce.
  • Banana Pudding – Start with cream cheese and add some banana slices and a few ‘Nilla Wafers.
  • Movie Matinee Bagel – Beginning with cream cheese, top with your favorite movie theater snacks. Try Cracker Jacks and Goobers or buttered popcorn with M&Ms.

The options and combinations are endless. Getting creative with this traditional breakfast item can produce delicious snacks and even desserts when you’re looking for something a little less traditional.

Read more

Bagel Fun Facts

NYB featured in Huffington Post

“Bagels are My Life…” We’re so proud that New Yorker Bagels founder George Menegatos recently received national attention with his captivating Huffington Post interview. Read the full article  

Read more
Healthy Bagels

How Healthy Can A Bagel Be?

It’s common that as a food gets more popular, the less healthy it becomes. Many fast food joints prove this theory, and as bagels have hit the mainstream as a go-to breakfast or snack, certain modi...

Read more