Enjoy FREE Overnight Shipping*! Order now.

Enjoy FREE Overnight Shipping*! Order now.

New York Bagels - Gift

Gourmet NYC Holiday Gift Shop

Hand-Rolled in NYC  ~   Add a Gift Note
Shipped Fresh with Overnight Shipping Included

Gourmet New York Bagel Gifts

Hand-Rolled in NYC & Shipped Fresh
Add a Gift Note
Overnight Shipping Included

Hanukkah bagels

Blue-Swirled Hanukkah Bagels 

Celebrate Hanukkah by sending your loved-ones a box of the world's only blue-swirled Hanukkah bagels!
Free Overnight Shipping.

$39.50

red Christmas bagels

Red-Swirled Christmas Bagels

Available for a short time only! Our hand-rolled plain NYC bagels with a special red-swirl added to the dough.
Free Overnight Shipping.

$39.50

Bagel Gift

1 Dozen NYC Gift Box

Send an impressive gift box of hand-rolled NYC bagels to someone special! Always baked to order.
Free Overnight Shipping.

$39.50

bagel of the month

Bagel-of-the-Month Gift

A gift of New York City that keeps giving, includes the most popular bagels shipped fresh each month.
Free Overnight Shipping.

starts at $112


Bagels with Spreads

1 Dozen Box with Spreads

Choose 2 different hand-rolled NYC bagel flavors and we add 12 spread packs to top 'em! An impressive gift filled with fresh New York City Bagels.
Free Overnight Shipping.

$49.75

bagel gift box

3 Dozen Box with Spreads

Send an incredible assortment by selecting 6 flavors, and save big-time (vs. 1 dozen) on 36 hand-rolled NYC bagels + spread packs.
Free Overnight Shipping.

$99


Rainbow Bagels

Rainbow Bagels

NEW! Delight someone with our gorgeous, handmade Rainbow Bagels—they taste as good as they look!
Free Overnight Shipping.

$39.95

ORDER

2 Dozen Gift Box

You select 4 fresh-baked flavors to build a large custom box of New York's finest bagels. 
Free Overnight Shipping.

$64.50

ORDER

Fresh NYC Gift Cards

Shopping for someone else but not sure what to give? Just send the gift of hand-rolledness! We email these, so you can print out or just forward away!

$25 - $200

Purchase Gift Card

Need to send a lotta gifts? Corporate gifts?
Contact us
for our corporate order form.
Just send us your list and we'll take care of everything!

Need to send a lotta gifts? Corporate gifts?
Contact us
for our corporate order form. Just send us your list and we'll take care of everything!

What do New Yorkers think of our hand-rolled bagels?

All of our bagels:

  • Rolled By Hand in New York City
  • Shipped fresh - overnight shipping included
  • No preservatives of any kind
  • Certified Star-K Kosher
  • Packed in a New Yorker Bagels gift box
  • Add a gift message

All of our bagels:

  • Rolled By Hand in New York City
  • Shipped fresh Priority Overnight included
  • No preservatives of any kind
  • Certified Star-K Kosher
  • Packed in a New Yorker Bagels gift box
  • Add a gift message


Stay fresh! Follow us:
Facebook Instagram Pinterest Twitter