FREE 2-Day Shipping from NYC! Order now

FREE 2-Day Shipping from NYC! Order now

This Year's Best Bagel Toppings

best bagel toppings

New Bagel Toppings To Try!

If you share our passion for hand-rolled NYC bagels, you're in for a treat! We’ve scoured the bagel landscape to bring you the most mind-blowing toppings to kick off 2024.

Granola and Peanut Butter

Peanut Butter & Granola

Spread the love with creamy peanut butter and a crunchy granola twist. your bagel game with this irresistible and energy-boosting combo!

Everything Bagel next to pizza toppings

Pizza Bagel

Upgrade your bagel to a pizza paradise with tomato sauce, gooey mozzarella, pepperoni, and your favorite toppings. Adult-sized Bagel Bites, anyone?


Slices of pastramiPastrami

Straight from the Jewish deli playbook – pastrami, cheese, sauerkraut, and grainy mustard – a bagel sandwich fit for royalty.


Elvis Presley dancing

The "Elvis"

Satisfy your cravings with the King's favorite combo: peanut butter, banana, and bacon – a strangely magical flavor medley.

Plain Bagel next to burger toppings

Bagel Burger

Why settle for buns when you can have bagels? Top your favorite bagel with a burger patty, cheese, and all the fixings.


Cranberry Energy Bagel next to a bowl of cookie dough

Cookie Dough

Dessert lovers, rejoice! Stuff your favorite bagel with edible cookie dough for the ultimate sweet treat.