FREE 2-Day Shipping from NYC! Order

FREE 2-Day Shipping from NYC! Order

Pumpernickel Bagels - 2 Dozen

$44.00 $64.00

If you enjoy a topping on any other bagel, odds are you will like it on a New York Pumpernickel too! That said, there are some time-tested toppings that can take a tasty plain New Yorker Pumpernickel Bagel to a new level of flavor: any kind of spread is a winner, but salmon or pimento go particularly well.

You get 2 dozen fresh, hand-rolled NYC Pumpernickel bagels, shipped fresh to you with free 2-day shipping. No preservatives, no saturated fat, Star-K, pas Yisroel Kosher certified.

Customer Reviews

Based on 87 reviews
95%
(83)
0%
(0)
3%
(3)
1%
(1)
0%
(0)
L
Leo Grandovic
Best bagels

Pure and simple, these are the best bagels I have ever eaten bar none!

J
Joe Becker
Six Star Bagels

When i was last in NYC i was in bagel heaven. Where I live i had to drive one town over to get Pumpernickel at all and then only on Sunday. Then they stopped stocking them.

Now that you are sending them too me I'm in bagel heaven again.

J
Jemima Post

Pumpernickel Bagels

R
Robin Rinearson
Fantastic flavor and consistency

Delicious! Not flat, hard, overly dense. Just right toasted with a shmear.

V
Virginia Majewski
Awesome!

The pumpernickel bagels were the best we’ve ever had! They came when promised and were so fresh. We’ll definitely order them again!

R
Ronnie Schechter
Love them

Very happy you make pumpernickel

B
Barb D.
Be aware of quick mold

My bagels started showing mold on Day 4, one day after the 3 day mold warning. Warning is very accurate! With 2 days of shipping, upon arrival they must be eaten or frozen ASAP. Due to shipping days and quick mold, I cannot recommend these bagels.

Hi Barb,

Thank you for taking the time to leave a review. As stated on the website, at checkout and on the pamphlet that is inserted into the box with the bagels, our bagels do not contain any preservatives and must be frozen upon receipt. Our bagels turning moldy is an indication that our products are baked fresh and 100% free of preservatives. Please reach out to us at fresh-baked@newyorkerbagels.com if you need further assistance.

Sincerely,
Fresh Customer Service
New Yorker Bagels

Customer Reviews

Based on 87 reviews
95%
(83)
0%
(0)
3%
(3)
1%
(1)
0%
(0)
L
Leo Grandovic
Best bagels

Pure and simple, these are the best bagels I have ever eaten bar none!

J
Joe Becker
Six Star Bagels

When i was last in NYC i was in bagel heaven. Where I live i had to drive one town over to get Pumpernickel at all and then only on Sunday. Then they stopped stocking them.

Now that you are sending them too me I'm in bagel heaven again.

J
Jemima Post

Pumpernickel Bagels

R
Robin Rinearson
Fantastic flavor and consistency

Delicious! Not flat, hard, overly dense. Just right toasted with a shmear.

V
Virginia Majewski
Awesome!

The pumpernickel bagels were the best we’ve ever had! They came when promised and were so fresh. We’ll definitely order them again!

R
Ronnie Schechter
Love them

Very happy you make pumpernickel

B
Barb D.
Be aware of quick mold

My bagels started showing mold on Day 4, one day after the 3 day mold warning. Warning is very accurate! With 2 days of shipping, upon arrival they must be eaten or frozen ASAP. Due to shipping days and quick mold, I cannot recommend these bagels.

Hi Barb,

Thank you for taking the time to leave a review. As stated on the website, at checkout and on the pamphlet that is inserted into the box with the bagels, our bagels do not contain any preservatives and must be frozen upon receipt. Our bagels turning moldy is an indication that our products are baked fresh and 100% free of preservatives. Please reach out to us at fresh-baked@newyorkerbagels.com if you need further assistance.

Sincerely,
Fresh Customer Service
New Yorker Bagels

If you enjoy a topping on any other bagel, odds are you will like it on a New York Pumpernickel too! That said, there are some time-tested toppings that can take a tasty plain New Yorker Pumpernickel Bagel to a new level of flavor: any kind of spread is a winner, but salmon or pimento go particularly well.

You get 2 dozen fresh, hand-rolled NYC Pumpernickel bagels, shipped fresh to you with free 2-day shipping. No preservatives, no saturated fat, Star-K, pas Yisroel Kosher certified.

Customer Reviews

Based on 87 reviews
95%
(83)
0%
(0)
3%
(3)
1%
(1)
0%
(0)
L
Leo Grandovic
Best bagels

Pure and simple, these are the best bagels I have ever eaten bar none!

J
Joe Becker
Six Star Bagels

When i was last in NYC i was in bagel heaven. Where I live i had to drive one town over to get Pumpernickel at all and then only on Sunday. Then they stopped stocking them.

Now that you are sending them too me I'm in bagel heaven again.

J
Jemima Post

Pumpernickel Bagels

R
Robin Rinearson
Fantastic flavor and consistency

Delicious! Not flat, hard, overly dense. Just right toasted with a shmear.

V
Virginia Majewski
Awesome!

The pumpernickel bagels were the best we’ve ever had! They came when promised and were so fresh. We’ll definitely order them again!

R
Ronnie Schechter
Love them

Very happy you make pumpernickel

B
Barb D.
Be aware of quick mold

My bagels started showing mold on Day 4, one day after the 3 day mold warning. Warning is very accurate! With 2 days of shipping, upon arrival they must be eaten or frozen ASAP. Due to shipping days and quick mold, I cannot recommend these bagels.

Hi Barb,

Thank you for taking the time to leave a review. As stated on the website, at checkout and on the pamphlet that is inserted into the box with the bagels, our bagels do not contain any preservatives and must be frozen upon receipt. Our bagels turning moldy is an indication that our products are baked fresh and 100% free of preservatives. Please reach out to us at fresh-baked@newyorkerbagels.com if you need further assistance.

Sincerely,
Fresh Customer Service
New Yorker Bagels